When AI Pilots Crash Before Take-off
It’s a hard truth: 95% of enterprise AI pilots fail to deliver measurable ROI, despite billions in investment (MIT Media Lab).
For insurance executives, the stakes are even higher. Every failed AI pilot is not just wasted time and budget. It is a missed chance to cut claims costs, speed underwriting, and strengthen compliance. Worse, failed pilots fuel internal scepticism and slow transformation.
It doesn’t have to be this way. Let’s explore why AI pilots often stall — and how to make yours succeed.
Pitfall 1: Vague Goals, No Strategic Focus
Too many pilots start with the wrong intent: to “experiment with AI” or “see what it can do.” Without business alignment, KPIs, or urgency, projects drift. Success becomes impossible to measure.
Example:
A regional insurer deployed an AI tool to summarize claims documentation. Technically it worked, but since it wasn’t tied to a cost or efficiency metric, no one could prove value. The pilot was shelved.
How to Fix It:
Tie AI directly to measurable outcomes. Reduce FNOL handling time by 50%. Auto-approve low-risk claims. Improve quote-to-bind efficiency in SMB underwriting. With Connect6, insurers can define and track such metrics from day one, ensuring pilots stay business-driven.
Pitfall 2: Data Without Context
Even the best model fails without complete data. Insurance systems often span decades, creating silos across policy, claims, risk scoring, and vendor information. AI without full context delivers low trust and high abandonment.
Example:
A fraud detection model flagged anomalies based only on payment speed and loss descriptions. Lacking vendor history or subrogation data, it produced false positives and was abandoned.
How to Fix It:
Feed AI with the full insurance context. Model6 ingests data across policy, claims, and risk systems to deliver predictions your teams and regulators can trust. Fraud detection, churn prediction, and pricing optimization become reliable when grounded in complete data.
Pitfall 3: No Workflow Integration, No Adoption
If AI lives in a separate dashboard, it will fail — not because it’s wrong, but because it’s disconnected from how teams actually work.
Example:
An underwriting team ignored AI-generated risk scores because they had to log into a separate system. SLAs suffered and the model was abandoned.
How to Fix It:
AI must live inside the workflow. Bay6.ai products integrate into claims, underwriting, and CRM platforms so insights appear exactly where decisions are made. No extra clicks, no extra friction — just augmented productivity.
Pitfall 4: No Governance, No Green Light
Without governance, AI becomes a black box. If teams or auditors can’t explain why a claim was denied, a quote rejected, or fraud flagged, adoption stalls.
A recent survey showed that while 82% of insurance leaders consider AI a priority, only 22% have deployed it at scale. The number one barrier? Lack of governance.
How to Fix It:
Operationalize trust. Forge6 equips insurers with pre-launch audits, ethics boards, and decision-logging frameworks so every AI output is traceable and defensible. Governance doesn’t slow innovation. It makes scaling possible.
Where AI Actually Works in Insurance
The fastest path to AI success is starting where value and feasibility meet:
- Claim triage: Automate routing of low-risk claims to reduce adjuster load.
- Fraud pre-screening: Use pattern detection to flag anomalies across vendors, regions, and policy types.
- Low-complexity underwriting: Auto-approve small commercial quotes under defined thresholds.
- Document validation: Instantly check for missing fields or mismatched IDs at FNOL intake.
These use cases are high-volume, low-risk, and deeply measurable. They deliver early wins that build trust and ROI.
Final Thought: Don’t Pilot to “Test AI.” Pilot to Win.
AI in insurance is not a novelty. It is a necessary capability. But only when pilots are designed to succeed.
Bay6.ai helps insurers launch AI initiatives with discipline and ROI focus:
- Connect6 → Automates service workflows and claims conversations with measurable impact.
- Model6 → Turns insurance data into predictive intelligence for pricing, fraud detection, and retention.
- Forge6 → Builds governance and roadmaps that scale AI responsibly across business lines.
Every pilot is built to go live, scale fast, and prove value.
Let’s build an AI pilot that doesn’t crash. Start free with Bay6.ai or book a demo today.
Talk to us. Let’s build what moves the needle.
Book a Demo
